Wfm_calder | FIR Creations
Art, Craft and Creativity,  Uncategorized

Soooo….You Call That Art? (What is Art?)

Many of us have said this from time to time. And many of us who are in the art field have heard it about our own art as well as that of others. I admit I may have said it a time or ten in my life.

The great debate over what is art and what isn’t art has gone on for a very long time. Here are just a few various ideas of what art is or is not. They all make you think (much like art itself):

Art is not what you see, but what you make others see.
~ Edgar Degas

It would be possible to describe everything scientifically, but it would make no sense; it would be without meaning, as if you described a Beethoven symphony as a variation of wave pressure. 
~Albert Einstein

When words become unclear, I shall focus with photographs. When images become inadequate, I shall be content with silence.
~ Ansel Adams

Leaf_AnselAdams | FIR Creations

The aim of art is to represent not the outward appearance of things, but their inward significance.
~Aristotle

He who works with his hands is a laborer.
He who works with his hands and his head is a craftsman.
He who works with his hands and his head and his heart is an artist.
~ Francis of Assisi

Is Art Synonymous With Beauty?

example of dramatic artistic photography | FIR Creations

Many think art has to be beautiful (their version of beautiful) to be classified as art. So, what is art?

There are incredible works of art that are not necessarily beautiful. (We can talk about beauty some other time.) Have you seen dramatic and moving photos from events that have occurred in history? Take this one for example, a dark, dramatic image of a tornado. Can this be thought of as beautiful? Can we look at it and not feel some pain in our hearts for all those whose lives, homes and businesses may be destroyed?  It’s a dramatic image and the feelings it brings up are very real: fear, sadness, and maybe a little smile, as a nod to a certain movie we grew up with, featuring a cyclone and a little girl who got lost over the rainbow. Some pieces of art are linked to a very sad time or disturbing situations, and they certainly elicit negative emotions. AND they can be classified as art, due to the fact that they are specifically photographed or rendered to create emotion.

So, if someone creates something that doesn’t fit into our definition of beauty, we need to think about what thought or feeling it may provoke. If the feeling is unpleasant, it doesn’t change it to non-art. If anything is felt, then the artist has accomplished their goal.

Has a painting, photo or sculpture causes you to think? Discuss? Philosophise? Even laugh (in a non-mocking way)? If so, then my friend, you have been in contact with a piece of art.

Art Defined

The simplest and most concise definition of art in my own words is:
Art is any creation that causes emotions, encourages thoughts and ideas or portrays beliefs.

There are many aspects of art and creativity, a great number have generated many debates and discussions:

  • Form over Function, something that has been debated for decades, centuries maybe even millenia.
  • The old competition between painters and sculptors, which is real art?
  • What about current debates over whether rendering art by hand is better than digital? Can digital art be “as legitimate” as hand-rendered art?
  • Art vs. Craft
Tajines in a pottery shop in Morocco | FIR Creations

And can someone tape a banana to a wall and call it art? All fun subjects for FRIENDLY debate and discussion.

Click “Comment” and let me know whether this article has enlightened you or if it helped to confirm what you already believe.
Which of the famous quotes spoke the most to you about art?

Image Credits (in order of appearance):

Image:  L’empennage –
Artist: Alexander Calder
 (Pictured in 2002 when it was displayed in the sculpture garden of the Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art)
Credits: All information pertaining to this image is here.

Image: Close-up of leaves, “In Glacier National Park,” Montana
Artist: 
Ansel Adams
Credits: All information pertaining to this image is here.

Image: Cyclone
Artist: Photo by Nikolas Noonan on Unsplash

Image: Tajines in a pottery shop in Morocco
Credits: All information pertaining to this image is here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *